Sensitivity Analysis of DL Perception Models to Sensing Parameters

Sensitivity Analysis of Deep-Learning Perception Models to Sensing Parameters (Sielemann, Bitzer et al., 2026)

2196

subdatasets

43

classes

4300

images per dataset

9442800

total images

In the study of deep learning-based models and deep neural networks (DNN), measuring their sensitivity or robustness against perturbations has been a key focus. This is especially relevant for safety-critical applications, such as fully-automated vehicles on public roads, which need to demonstrate-besides robustness against intentional adversarial manipulations-the robustness under all conditions of their operational design domain (ODD). In this context, the specific understanding of how deep learning models are affected by ODD aspects is crucial to assure safe and reliable operation.

We present an approach to systematically evaluate the sensitivity of DNNs to variations in environmental conditions through the use of physically-based synthetic data, demonstrated on the task of traffic sign recognition. For this task, we leverage the data synthesis pipeline from our previous work on the Synset Signset Germany dataset, for which the comparability to real-world data was demonstrated. This pipeline is used to create a large-scale systematic dataset of perturbations with physical, exposure-related meaning, including 2,196 subdatasets, accumulating to 9,442,800 test images. This dataset is provided as open data to serve as a basis for further in-depth investigations into the performance of DNNs under challenging conditions.

The application of our testing approach indicates that the performance of DNNs can be related to the physical parameters of input image data and that the sensitivity to these parameters can be measured to a significant and reproducible degree; however, the results show high variation and complexity in the behavior of the evaluated DNNs that extend beyond simple data quality models.

Synset Signset Sensitivity Analysis Datasets

FieldTaskLicenseSamplesKey AnnotationsInstitutions
Computer Visiontraffic sign recognitionCreative Commons License
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
4,300 independent images per subdataset,
9,442,800 images in total
Per frame: Class (sign type), environment conditions (e.g., time of day, contrast), imaging artifacts (noise, motion blur, chromatic aberration), semantic segmentation, binary mask.Fraunhofer IOSB,
KIT-IES
Key properties of the dataset.

Included traffic sign classes (expand)

The Synset Signset Sensitivity Analysis datasets comprise the same classes as the well-known “German Traffic Sign Recognition Benchmark“ (GTSRB)1 dataset. The class IDs directly match the traffic sign class IDs of GTSRB.

1 J. Stallkamp, M. Schlipsing, J. Salmen, and C. Igel, “The German traffic sign recognition benchmark: a multi-class classification competition,”
in The 2011 international joint conference on neural networks. IEEE, 2011, pp. 1453–1460.

IDNameImage
0Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 20
1Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 30
2Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 50
3Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 60
4Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 70
5Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 80
6Ende der zulässigen Höchst­geschwindigkeit 80
7Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 100
8Zulässige Höchstgeschwindigkeit 120
9Überholverbot für Kraftfahrzeuge aller Art
10Überholverbot für Kraftfahrzeuge über 3,5 t
11Vorfahrt
12Vorfahrtstraße
13Vorfahrt gewähren
14Halt. Vorfahrt gewähren
IDNameImage
15Verbot für Fahrzeuge aller Art
16Verbot für Kraftfahr­zeuge über 3,5 t
17Verbot der Einfahrt
18Gefahrenstelle
19Kurve – links
20Kurve – rechts
21Doppelkurve – zunächst links
22Unebene Fahrbahn
23Schleuder- oder Rutschgefahr
24Einseitig verengte Fahrbahn – Verengung rechts
25Arbeitsstelle
26Lichtzeichenanlage
27Fußgänger – Aufstellung rechts
28Kinder – Aufstellung rechts
29Radverkehr – Aufstellung rechts
IDNameImage
30Schnee- oder Eisglätte
31Wildwechsel – Aufstellung rechts
32Ende sämtlicher streckenbezogener Geschwindigkeitsbeschränkungen und Überholverbote
33Vorgeschriebene Fahrtrichtung – rechts
34Vorgeschriebene Fahrtrichtung – links
35Vorgeschriebene Fahrtrichtung – geradeaus
36Vorgeschriebene Fahrtrichtung – geradeaus oder rechts
37Vorgeschriebene Fahrtrichtung – geradeaus oder links
38Vorgeschriebene Vorbeifahrt – rechts vorbei
39Vorgeschriebene Vorbeifahrt – links vorbei
40Kreisverkehr
41Ende des Überholverbotes für Kraftfahrzeuge aller Art
42Ende des Überholverbotes für Kraftfahrzeuge über 3,5 t

Environment selection (expand)

All HDRIs used by the rendering pipeline for lighting and background modulation stem from Polyhaven1. In total, 523 environment maps were used, their names are given in the following tabular.

1 Poly Haven

Abandoned ChurchFarm FieldMpumalanga VeldSimon's Town Rocks
Abandoned Hopper Terminal 01Farm SunsetMud RoadSisulu
Abandoned Hopper Terminal 02FelsenlabyrinthMuddy Autumn ForestSkate Park
Abandoned Hopper Terminal 03Fish Eagle HillMuseum of HistorySkidpan
Abandoned Hopper Terminal 04Fish Hoek BeachMuseumpleinSkukuza Golf
Abandoned ParkingFlower HillsideNagoya Wall PathSmall Harbor 01
Abandoned PathwayFlower RoadNarrow Moonlit RoadSmall Harbor 02
Abandoned SlipwayForest CaveNature Reserve ForestSmall Harbour Morning
Abandoned Tank Farm 01Forest GroveNear The River 01Small Harbour Sunset
Abandoned Tank Farm 02Forest SlopeNear The River 02Small Rural Road
Abandoned Tank Farm 03Forgotten MinilandNetball CourtSmall Rural Road 02
Abandoned Tank Farm 04Fouriesburg Mountain CloudyNeuer ZollhofSnow Field
Abandoned Tank Farm 05Fouriesburg Mountain LookoutNeurathen Rock CastleSnow Field 2
Abandoned WaterworksFouriesburg Mountain Lookout 2Niederwihl ForestSnowy Cemetery
AhornsteigFouriesburg Mountain MiddayNight BridgeSnowy Field
Air Museum PlaygroundFreight StationNinomaru TeienSnowy Forest
Aloe Farm Shade HouseFrozen LakeNkuhluSnowy Forest Path 01
Alps FieldFurry CloudsNogaSnowy Forest Path 02
AltankaFuture ParkingNoon GrassSnowy Hillside
Amphitheatre Zanzibar FortGamrigNorthcliffSnowy Hillside 02
Approaching StormGarden NookOberer KuhbergSnowy Park 01
ArboretumGeislingen An Der SteigeOld Outdoor TheaterSoliltude
Aristea WreckGlencairn ExpresswayOld Quarry GerlingenSolitude Night
Autumn CrossingGoegapOld Tree in City ParkSpaichingen Hill
Autumn FieldGoegap RoadOrbitaSpiaggia di Mondello
Autumn Forest 01Golden BayOrlando StadiumSpree Bank
Autumn Forest 02Golf Course SunriseOstrich RoadSpruit Dawn
Autumn Forest 03Gothic Manor 01Ouchy PierSpruit Sunrise
Autumn Forest 04Gothic Manor 02Outdoor UmbrellasSt. Peters Square Night
Autumn GroundGraveyard PathwaysOutdoor WorkshopStadium 01
Autumn HockeyGray PierOvercast SoilSteinbach Field
Autumn MeadowGreen Point ParkOvercast Soil 2Sterkspruit Falls
Autumn ParkGreen SanctuaryOx Bridge MorningStone Alley
Autumn RoadGreenwich ParkPalermo ParkStone Alley 02
Aviation MuseumGreenwich Park 02Palermo SidewalkStone Alley 03
Aviation Museum HillGreenwich Park 03Palermo SquareStone Pines
BalconyGum TreesParched CanalStraw Rolls Field 01
Beach Cloudy BridgeHamburg CanalPark BenchStream
Beach ParkingHanger Exterior CloudyPark ParkingStreet Lamp
Belfast FarmhouseHansaplatzPartial EclipseStudio Garden
Belfast Open FieldHartiesPedestrian OverpassStuttgart Hillside
Belfast SunsetHarvestPetit PortStuttgart Suburbs
Bell Park DawnHerkulessäulenPfälzer Forest 01Suburban Field 01
Bell Park PierHilltop ConstructionPiazza BologniSuburban Field 02
BelvedereHilly Terrain 01Piazza Martin LuteroSuburban Parking Area
BergenHochsal FieldPiazza San MarcoSummer Stage 01
Bethnal Green EntranceHochsal ForestPink SunriseSummer Stage 02
Between BridgesHotel Rooftop BalconyPizzo PerniceSunflowers
BinnenalsterIllovo Beach BalconyPondSunny Vondelpark
BirchwoodImmenstädter HornPond Bridge NightSunset Fairway
BismarckturmIndustrial SunsetPoolSunset Forest
Bismarckturm HillsideIndustrial Sunset 02Portland Landing padSunset in the Chalk Quarry
Blau RiverJ&E Gray 02Potsdamer PlatzSyferfontein 0d Clear
Blaubeuren Church SquareJ&E Gray ParkPreller DriveSyferfontein 1d Clear
Blaubeuren HillsideJoburg Central SunsetPretville StreetSyferfontein 6d Clear
Blaubeuren NightKiara 1 DawnPromenade De VidySyferfontein 18d Clear
Blaubeuren OutskirtsKiara 2 SunrisePump StationSymmetrical Garden
Blouberg Sunrise 1Kiara 3 MorningPylonsSymmetrical Garden 02
Blouberg Sunrise 2Kiara 4 Mid-MorningQuarry 01Table Mountain 1
Blue GrottoKiara 5 NoonQuarry 02Table Mountain 2
Blue LagoonKiara 6 AfternoonQuarry 03Tears of Steel Bridge
Blue Lagoon NightKiara 7 Late-AfternoonQuarry 04Teatro Massimo
Borghese GardensKiara 8 SunsetQuarry CloudyTeufelsberg Ground 1
Brick Factory 01Kiara 9 DuskQuattro CantiTeufelsberg Ground 2
Brick Factory 02Killesberg ParkQwantaniTeufelsberg Roof
BuikslotermeerpleinKlippad Dawn 1Qwantani DawnThe Lost City
CambridgeKlippad Dawn 2Qwantani Dusk 1The Sky Is On Fire
Canary WharfKlippad Sunrise 1Qwantani Dusk 2Tiber 1
CannonKlippad Sunrise 2Qwantani PatioTiber 2
Cape HillKloetzle BleiQwantani SunriseTiber Island
Castel St. Angelo RoofKloofendal 28d MistyQwantani SunsetTief Etz
Cayley LookoutKloofendal 38d Partly CloudyRailway Bridge 02Tiergarten
Cedar BridgeKloofendal 43d ClearRailway BridgesTucker Wreck
Champagne Castle 1Kloofendal 48d Partly CloudyRainforest TrailTurning Area
Chapman's DriveKloofendal Misty MorningRathausUlmer Muenster
Chinese GardenKloofendal OvercastRed Hill CloudyUmhlanga Sunrise
Circus Maximus 1Kloppenheim 01Red Hill CurveUnder Bridge
Circus Maximus 2Kloppenheim 02Red Hill StraightUrban Alley 01
Citrus OrchardKloppenheim 03Red WallUrban Courtyard
Citrus Orchard RoadKloppenheim 04Reichstag 1Urban Courtyard 02
Clarens MiddayKloppenheim 05Reinforced Concrete 02Urban Street 01
Clarens Night 01Kloppenheim 06Residential GardenUrban Street 02
Clarens Night 02Kloppenheim 07Resting PlaceUrban Street 03
CliffsideKonigsalleeResting Place 2Urban Street 04
Cloud LayersKonzerthausRhodes MemorialVatican Road
Cloudy Cliffside RoadLago d'IsolaRiver RocksVeld Fire
Cloudy VondelparkLake PierRiver Walk 1Venetian Crossroads
Cobblestone Street NightLakesRiver Walk 2Venice Dawn 1
ColosseumLakesideRocky RidgeVenice Dawn 2
Construction YardLakeside DawnRogland Clear NightVenice Sunrise
Countrytrax MiddayLakeside SunriseRogland Moonlit NightVenice Sunset
CourtyardLaufenurg ChurchRogland OvercastVersveldpas
Courtyard NightLauter WaterfallRogland SunsetViale Giuseppe Garibaldi
CrosswalkLearner ParkRolling HillsVictoria Curve 01
Crystal FallsLeibstadtRoof GardenVictoria Curve 02
Dam BridgeLenong 1Roofless RuinsVictoria Sunset
Dam RoadLenong 2Rooftop DayVignaioli
Dam WallLenong 3Rooftop NightVignaioli Night
Dark Autumn ForestLiliensteinRooitou ParkWasteland Clouds
Delta 2LimehouseRosendal Mountain MidmorningWaterbuck Trail
Derelict Highway MiddayLimpopo Golf CourseRosendal Park SunsetWhipple Creek Gazebo
Derelict Highway NoonLittle Paris Eiffel TowerRosendal Plains 1Whipple Creek Regional Park 01
Derelict OverpassLittle Paris Under TowerRosendal Plains 2Whipple Creek Regional Park 04
Derelict UnderpassLonely Road AfternoonRotes RathausWhite Cliff Top
Dikhololo NightLot 01Round PlatformWide Street 01
Dikhololo SunsetLot 02RuckenkreuzWide Street 02
Dirt Bike Track 01Lush Dirt PathRural Asphalt RoadWildflower Field
Drackenstein QuarryLythwood FieldRural CrossroadsWinter Evening
Drakensberg Solitary MountainLythwood TerraceRural Graffiti TowerWinter Lake 01
DreifaltigkeitsbergMall Parking LotRural LandscapeWinter Orchard
Dresden MoatMeadowRural Winter RoadsideWinter River
Dresden SquareMeadow 2Rustig KoppieWinter Sky
Driving SchoolMealie RoadSabie TentWobbly Bridge
Dry Cracked LakeMedieval CafeSafari SunsetWooden Motel
Dry FieldMissile Launch Facility 02San Giuseppe BridgeWoods
Dry Hay FieldMissile Launch Facility 03SandslootXanderklinge
Dry MeadowMisty DawnSatara NightXiequ Yuan
Dry Orchard MeadowMisty Farm RoadSatara Night (No Lamps)Yellow Field
Dusseldorf BridgeMisty PinesSchachen ForestZavelstein
Ehingen HillsideModern BuildingsSchadowplatzZhengyang Gate
Ehingen Hillside 02Modern Buildings 2Scythian TombsZwartkops Curve Afternoon
Eilenriede LabyrinthModern Buildings NightScythian Tombs 2Zwartkops Curve Morning
Eilenriede ParkMonbachtal RiverbankSecluded BeachZwartkops Curve Sunset
EmmarentiaMonk's forestShady PatchZwartkops Start Afternoon
Epping Forest 01Monte ScherbelinoShanghai BundZwartkops Start Morning
Epping Forest 02MontorfanoShanghai RiversideZwartkops Start Sunset
EtzwihlMoonless GolfShudu LakeZwartkops Straight Afternoon
Evening FieldMoonlit GolfSignal Hill DawnZwartkops Straight Morning
Evening MeadowMossy ForestSignal Hill SunriseZwartkops Straight Sunset
Evening Road 01Moulton Falls Train Tunnel EastSimon's Town HarbourZwinger Night
Factory YardMoulton Station Train Tunnel WestSimon's Town Road

Metadata and label details (expand)

Mask images

The mask images mark all image areas showing the depicted traffic sign. They are given as binary png images containing only black and white pixels.

ClassRGBHex
Background000#000000
Foreground traffic sign shape255255255#ffffff

OGRE3D images

Semantic label images

Mask images

Semantic label images

The label images mark the different areas of the traffic sign itself, which enables to reconstruct the clean traffic sign and furthermore the sky, the traffic sign pole, other traffic signs, and tree parts that protrude into the picture. The labels are assigned as follows:

ClassRGBHex
Black areas of the traffic sign505050#323232
White areas of the traffic sign255255255#ffffff
Red areas of the traffic sign175075#af004b
Orange areas of the traffic sign22512525#e17d19
Yellow areas of the traffic sign20020075#c8c84b
Blue areas of the traffic sign0100125#00647d
Green areas of the traffic sign25150125#19967d
Tree50200158#32C89E
Sky150200200#96c8c8
Traffic sign pole1252575#7d194b
Label Mapping

JSON files

For each image the Synset Background Effect datasets contain a json file with the corresponding metadata. The json files include:

namerangeexampledescription
dataset“Synset – Sensitivity Analysis of Deep-Learning Perception Models to Sensing Parameters”“Synset – Sensitivity Analysis of Deep-Learning Perception Models to Sensing Parameters”Name of dataset
subdatasetNaming convention: Dataset-[motion blur pixels]-[additive noise level]
motion blur pixels from 0 to 35 in single pixel steps, additive noise level from 0.0 to 0.06 in 0.01 steps.
Dataset-2-0150Identifier of the (sub-)datasets. The dataset includes 2,196 subdatasets consisting of 36 motion blur steps x 61 additive noise steps.
image.baseID[0, …, 99]78Image’s base ID. Is between 0 and 99 since each subdataset class contains 100 images.
image.pathrelative file pathDataset-26-0160/19/11_img.pngRelative path to the image to which the json file refers.
image.width4848Width of the corresponding image.
image.height4848Height of the corresponding image.
geometry.renderingEngineOCTAS/OGRE3DOCTAS/OGRE3DFor all images of these datasets the OGRE3D render engine (rasterization) was used.
geometry.trafficSignClass[0, …, 42]
one of the 43 traffic sign classes
17Defines the depicted traffic sign’s class as id. All available IDs can be looked up in the previous section “Traffic sign selection”.
environment.nameSee previous section “Environment selection”Farm FieldName of the used Polyhaven environment map. In total, 523 different environment maps where used for the dataset generation (see previous section).
environment.dayTimeMorningAfternoon, SunriseSunset, Midday, Night, ‘NotSpecifiedMiddayDepicted time of day.
environment.basicLocationOutdoorOutdoorDepicted basic location.
environment.detailedLocationUrban, Suburban, Road, Rail, Nature, Beach, BelowBridge, Greenhouse, SpecialSuburbanDepicted detailed location.
environment.weatherClear, Overcast, PartlyCloudy, NotSpecifiedPartlyCloudyBasic weather information.
environment.contrastLowContrast, MediumContrast, HighContrast, NotSpecifiedHighContrastSpecified environment contrast.
environment.lightNatural, Artificial, NotSpecifiedNaturalDepicted light type. Indoor and night environments are typicalle illuminated by artificial light.
environment.seasonAutumn, Winter, Summer, NotSpecifiedSummerDepicted season. Unfortunately, this information is not available for some of the environment maps.
imageEffects.chromaticAberration.angle0.00.0Used angle for chromatic aberration given in radian.
imageEffects.chromaticAberration.pixels0.00.0Applied width of chromatic aberration in pixel.
imageEffects.motionBlur.angle[0.0, 2·pi)4.20759929278776Used angle for motion blur given in radian.
imageEffects.motionBlur.pixels[0, 35]24Applied width of motion blur in pixel.
imageEffects.globalBlurStdDev0.40.4Gaussian kernel standard deviation of overall blur added to image.
imageEffects.relativeNoiseLevel0.00.0Scales the relative noise.
imageEffects.additiveNoiseLevel[0.0, 0.6]0.4Scales the additive noise.
imageEffects.aecError0.00.0Automatic exposure correction error.
imageEffects.whitePointAccuracy1.01.0Accuracy of the white balance (0 = no correction, 1 = gray world).
imageEffects.flaresfalsefalseSpecifies whether lense flares where simulated or not.
imageEffects.digitalImageSharpening.sigma1.51.5Gaussian kernel standard deviation applied to receive the blured image for unsharp masking.
imageEffects.digitalImageSharpening.strength0.40.4Amount of unsharp masking.
imageEffects.digitalImageSharpening.threshold0.020.02Threshold from which difference between image and blur image the image is digitally sharpened.
imageEffects.bayerPatterntruetrueSpecifies whether bayer pattern artifacts where simulated or not.

Paper and reference

Creative Commons License This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.

To cite this work in your scientific publication, please use the following bibliography entry:

Sielemann, A., Bitzer, N., Roschani, M., Ziehn, J., and Beyerer, J. (2026). Sensitivity Analysis of Deep-Learning Perception Models to Sensing Parameters. In 2026 IEEE 29th International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITSC).

@inproceedings{sensitivity_analysis_sielemann_2026,
  title={{Sensitivity Analysis of Deep-Learning Perception Models to Sensing Parameters}},
  author={Sielemann, Anne and Bitzer, Niklas and Roschani, Masoud and Ziehn, Jens and Beyerer, Juergen},
  booktitle={2026 IEEE 29th International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITSC)},
  year={2026}
}

In case of copying and redistributing, or publishing an adapted version of our datasets, please provide the name of our dataset, the creator names, a copyright notice, a link to this website, a license notice with link to the license, and, if changes were made, a disclaimer notice, and a short description of the applied changes. For example, as follows:

This work is based on Sensitivity Analysis of Deep-Learning Perception Models to Sensing Parameters
by Anne Sielemann, Niklas Bitzer, Masoud Roschani, Jens Ziehn, and Juergen Beyerer,
© 2026 Fraunhofer IOSB, All rights reserved.
Link: https://synset.de/datasets/synset-signset-ger/sensitivity-analysis/
Licence: CC BY 4.0
Disclaimer: The original authors are neither affiliated nor responsible for any applied changes.

Paper for Personal Use

Credits

This work was funded in part by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy (BMWE) within the program “New Vehicle and System Technologies” as part of the AVEAS research project, and conducted within the scope of the KAMO: Karlsruhe Mobility High Performance Center.